Literature Reviews

A brief guide for various disciplines, including social work, other social sciences, human environmental sciences, and related disciplines

APMD, CSES, HORT, AECT, PLPA, HESC Agriculture Librarian

Necia Parker Gibson's picture
Necia Parker Gibson
Contact:
Mullins Library 220N

Email is the best way to contact me. neciap@uark.edu

I've set my office phone to forward to my cell phone. We'll see how that works.

I'm working from home starting 3/16/2020 until further notice. Email or use the text number below. If you want me, particularly, ask for me.

Text a librarian: 479-385-0803

For students, faculty, and staff I will:
Answer your questions via email, phone or Skype or Facetime (until we are back to face to face).
Recommend databases for your topic.
Meet individually to work out your topic or discuss research strategies.

For faculty, I will:
Provide in-person library instruction tailored to your class, or tailored research guides to your class, with some lead time.

Meet with your students individually or in small groups.
Track down tricky citations. Purchase books and other materials, as funds allow.

I do consultations via email, Skype or Facetime (as well as face to face, when we can again).
Email me for an appointment.
479-575-8421
Website

Chat with Us

Use databases:

Use the catalog and WorldCat to find books and databases to find dissertations and articles for the review. The QuickSearch box will find *some* of all these things. Ask a librarian for help!

What is a literature review?

The purpose of a literature review is to help ground yourself in the discipline and help you (and your readers) understand your topic in the context of the field or discipline. Note: The expectations for a literature or 'lit' review can vary by discipline and within a discipline; IF in doubt, consult your advisor/professor.

There are some general rules:

  • Immerse yourself in the written discourse so that you can answer: who's said what? when? was it significant? who disagrees? why? what's next?
  • Cover the relevant, important literature in the field (or top x, if x= number of sources specified); you will need to be able to justify your choices. Deciding what's relevant is part of the task.
  • Define what has been done and what needs to be done in an area of research
  • Connect the works into a coherent overview
  • Synthesize what's out there, specifying how it relates to your topic.

 

In addition:

A literature review is also a way to inform your own writing. What is the scope of most articles in your discipline? Is the literature oriented toward empirical or qualitiative studies? What are the most common methods? what are the most interesting ones? (Rampel, 2010, among others).

Requirements?

Literature reviews can be a class assignment, an introduction to a paper or research project, a stand-alone article, or an introduction to a larger work, such as a thesis or dissertation. If in doubt, ask your professor or advisor.

Read the assignment or review your notes to see what is required. Sometimes a specific number of sources is requested.

When you are finished, you should be able to discuss the work of the most prominent authors in some detail, and give a cogent overview, and preferably, a synthesis of the literature.

A literature review is about ideas, concepts, theories and hypotheses, results and projections. It is usually both a summary of what's known and an introduction to the research that you plan to do. It is not an explication of your own research, but you need to know what the evidence is, for and against your hypothesis or argument.

A lit review is not... but it should--

A literature review is not a bibliography, per se. It is not a research paper, although they often contain literature reviews. It does not usually discuss every possible work in the field-- but it should cover the relevant ones.

"The end?"

You are close to the end when you start running into the same authors, the names that your professors mention don't make you say "Who?" and you start to feel a sense of command or fluency in the topic. This takes time and effort.


Funny, but not so funny

Finding books on "how to"

If you do a subject search in the catalog with research methodology as a phrase you find a lot of titles that talk about this process.

A call number with a book means that it is on the shelves, unless it has "library annex" as a location. If you click on the title, you'll see the record and be able to tell if the book is available, or whether to request that it be pulled for you from the Annex. Some books have both print and online copies. Some are only online.